Go back in time

Show more

Oh, Protesting, you said…?

 



I have wanted to write about this for a while but why go through it if someone already did? Check out @BlackKnight10k. He basically went to the core of the subject: how to protest. Full disclosure: I am the product of public education. I started in a private university but only lasted one semester. It was stifling, enclosing, boring. Also, too expensive. I dropped out and registered in a public university. Best decision I took (my dad was not in agreement, but by that time I really did not care about anything he had to say). Like he feared I got right in with the wrong crowd. I was immediately drawn to the art, music and poli-sci majors. Trouble started early.

I also took part in many a protest when I was a wee gayling, drunk with knowledge and self-righteousness. We all think we are correct 98% of the time when we are twenty. Oh, that rush. I understand the students who are now protesting the genocide in Palestine. I feel their passion. If the protests would happen in my campus, I would go out with them and get between them and the police. Probably risk arrest, even though that would be really bad for me. I cringe at the shenanigans and the manipulation that some of them suffer, though. Because both things are possible at the same time: you can be right in demonstrating against injustice and blinded by the injustice that's been committed. 

Protestors are also being used by other agents. It comes with the territory. It happened with BLM. It happened when Wall Street was raked through the coals, it happened with the whole ANTIFA movement. There's always de-stabilizing forces at play when passions run deep. And that's something that people do not seem to have learned.





Oh yes. I’m all for protesting. But there's protesting and there's protesting. Chanting 'Genocide Joe' is lame performative political drama that really does not solve anything or advances the narrative or the discussion. If anything, it cheapens the fight.

It also helps the 'other side'. The side that does not care about the plead of the Palestinians. The side that only wants chaos because it's the best to de-stabilize the system. And it also distracts of many other political goals that should not be discarded at this point: the November elections.

This is the perfect opportunity for those nefarious agents to inject themselves in the narrative and create a space that allows for them to spread misinformation and anger. People in the U.S. are not very politically savvy, sadly. For most Americans, politics and Prom Night are very much the same thing. Sadly.




… and lastly, @MuellerSheWrote nails it :


Who knew that social media still worked? That poster on Twitter is correct: Nuance has never been the American way. 

Sad.

XOXO

P.S. keep the eye on the prize: don't forget to vote Democrat.

Comments

  1. I graduated from a private Methodist liberal arts college, and believe me, it was so very, very liberal. Protesting is good. However, these days there are players who will try and take protesting and turn it ugly because certain governments want things to go bad. Most of the time these agents move in from the edge, creating chaos as they go, trying to turn protests into weapons.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The question would be: did you have protests?
      Liberal Arts colleges are a different animal, though. And we all know that not all BLM protesters were with the movement. There'll always be bad apples who want to plant chaos in these movements...


      XOXO

      Delete
  2. Remember Kent State University and the protests of the Vietnam war? Yeah, I do. I wasn't on campus but nearby that day. Don't conflate the two. Anytime the purposely disruptive forces enter your protest, you have lost. And the anti-democracy forces (Thing 45's supporters) have entered this protest. Their goal is not to end the Gaza / Israel war - it is to enflame it, to make it grow, to keep it going.
    To see and study a peaceful protest --- look at the women's march on D.C., look at the Million Man march on D.C. No violence, no violent rhetoric. XOXO

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I actually went to Kent State!
      I was just next door in Cleveland. The whole thing was a clusterfuck.
      And you know the MAGAts and Russia will try and fuck things up because it's election year...
      I was a the Women's March here in Chi: there were families with babies in carriages, the fuckers could not go all ballistic without revealing themselves. And those grandmas would have pummeled them with their knitting supplies.

      XOXO

      Delete
  3. You have to know where you stand, completely, and don't just fall into the sound-bite protest, i.e. Fuck Joe Biden.
    And know who's protesting with you; other students or people with a political agenda to the protest.
    Lastly, don't give up; speaking up is the ultimate protest and we all need to do that.
    xoxo

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The whole Fuck Joe Biden thing is asinine.
      But nobody is gonna tell them. There were many students, yes, but there were also scores of people not related to the university at all. It's the problem with protests like these.

      XOXO

      Delete
  4. Protesting is good for the soul but you have to use your brain about the issues as well. Not every protester has a good grasp on things or the nuances of the situation.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It's too emotional.
      These people are letting their emotions rule them and that's their downfall. Good intentions, but we all know the road to hell is paved with those...

      XOXO

      Delete
  5. I agree with this post. I am worried how ever about Biden. He's not getting the young vote like the last election. I read where the demographics have changed both he and the dump. Like POC is stronger for the dump now . which makes me say why?

    Protesting is good when done correct . if they are just swept up in the moment...they won't learn a thing or do any good.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The young vote may decide the future of this country.
      If they don't think, they may fuck up their own lives....
      Cheeto has a very limited appeal among POC... yes, there's some idiots who think they'll be ok, but they'll pay for that...

      XOXO

      Delete
  6. I rather despise how the protests have become about protesting, rather than focus on the issue they are trying to affect. The media, of course, is partially responsible for this perception, and there are also bad actors among the protesters - agents who seek to sew chaos in general. The message is getting lost. I think what they are asking for is admirable. But the way they are going about it reprehensible. Given that these are halls of higher learning, this could have been a teaching moment - how to resolve conflict in a civilized manner. At the same time... genocide is no time to be silent. So.... yes... make your voice heard, enact change... but the moment the police get involved? You've lost your focus, you've lost your movement, you've lost your message.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Oh, the protests are too emotional.
      It's the first time the Millennials have found anything like this and it's their shiny object. I agree that what they're asking for is admirable (to stop a genocide) but I don't think it's something they can just 'get'.
      I hope they keep talking but I also hope they implement change without being nihilistic...

      XOXO

      Delete
  7. I think it is possible to support the State of Israel and Palestine at the same time, while criticizing N's truly criminal policies. And then I think that, at the same time, it is possible to vote for J.B. who, although not a genius, is still better than D.T.
    love the map #8.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Of course it is possible.
      Both Palestine and Israel are fucked up right now. But if there's no war, Bibi will have to respond to justice and Hamas is chaotic. It's a clusterfuck of fuckery and blood.

      XOXO

      Delete
  8. Anonymous5/06/2024

    Protesters have to be careful of and watch for agent provocateurs in their midst and among their counter-protesters. Also be mindful of police departments , state and federal agencies with rogue elements that infiltrate to cause chaos to discredit and destroy your cause. -Rj

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Oh, absolutely.
      And you know that local governments will call the po-po. It's their go-to for social unrest. They need to look at the Women's March and decide what is it that they are doing WRONG.

      XOXO

      Delete

Post a Comment

Go ahead, give it to me.

Translate

Followers

Popular Posts

En otra lengua

  • Petro en Rimax - [image: Petro busca en barrios populares lo que no encuentra en el Congreso] El presidente ha decidido abandonar su gobierno. Se ha parado del sillĂ³n...
    4 days ago
  • ZORRA, LO TIENES COMPLICADO - No tenĂ­a intenciĂ³n de escribir nada sobre EurovisiĂ³n, de hecho y aunque parezca increĂ­ble dada mi sequĂ­a intelectual habitual, tenĂ­a hasta otro post med...
    1 week ago
  • Los estudiantes - Me encontraba todavĂ­a en el periplo familiar de lado a lado del AtlĂ¡ntico cuando todo comenzĂ³. Noticias e imĂ¡genes aterradoras llenaban las pĂ¡ginas de ...
    1 week ago
  • El amigo imaginario de mi madre. - Relato de Pablo Castignani Dicen que los niños suelen tener amigos imaginarios. Dicen tambiĂ©n que algunos ancianos llegan a comportarse como niños....
    2 weeks ago
  • - En los dĂ­as que se han convertido en años, en tiempo que transcurre y sin entenderme a mi mismo en mis angustias, en mis silencios, en mis ruidos que no c...
    4 years ago

Restricted to Adults

Restricted to Adults
Under 18? Beat it. Now.